Skip to content
Tag & Tether

Pets · Dog & Cat Trackers

SATELLAI vs Tractive vs Fi

Three collars that all need a plan to work. The specs differ less than the plans do, and the plan is where the money is.

By Mike M.Last updated

#ad — we earn a commission if you buy through the links on this page, at no cost to you, from Amazon and from brand partner programs. It never changes the order: our top pick is routinely the cheapest option to own over three years rather than the best-paying one. Full disclosure.


For most owners Tractive is still the right buy, because it has the cheapest plan of the three at $252 over thirty-six months and clips to the collar the dog already wears. Buy the SATELLAI Collar instead if you specifically want a virtual fence and a tracker in one unit — that is the thing it does which the other two do not. Buy Fi if you want the tracker built into the collar itself and you are willing to commit to a membership whose rate the company does not publish where we can cite it.

All three need a plan. None of them works without one, and in all three cases the plan outruns the hardware if you keep the collar for three years. That is the comparison that matters, so it goes first rather than last.

The three-year plan cost, which is the real difference

CollarPublished monthly rateAcross 36 months
Tractive$9 Basic on a 1-year term, $6 Basic on a 2-year term$252 — a 2-year term at $144 plus a 1-year at $108
SATELLAI“Telecom plans starting at $8.49/mo.”, per SATELLAI's product page$305.64 at the cheapest rate SATELLAI advertises
FiNot published on Fi's site; the listing states a membership is requiredUnknown — we will not print a figure we cannot cite

SATELLAI's plan is roughly $54 more than Tractive's across three years at each brand's cheapest advertised rate. That is not a disqualification — it is one collar doing two jobs, and a standalone GPS fence system costs considerably more than $54 — but it does mean SATELLAI is the wrong pick if all you want is to know where the dog is. Every tracker subscription on this site, costed the same way.

What each brand publishes

SATELLAI CollarTractiveFi Series 3+
FormThe collar is the tracker, 14"–30" neckA module that clips to any collarThe collar is the tracker
Stated batteryUp to 3 days active, up to 10 days standby, 1600 mAhCharge every few daysThe longest claim in cellular pet tracking
Virtual fenceUnlimited virtual fences, with customizable feedbackVirtual fence alertsEscape detection tied to your home Wi-Fi
PositioningDual-band GNSS, 5 constellations, dual antennas; LTE updates stated every second across 680+ networksCellular with a built-in SIM, live tracking with a walk-to-it modeCellular, with escape detection via home Wi-Fi
Water ratingIP68Not published in the form we citeNot published in the form we cite
Two-way audioYesNoNo
PlanRequired, from $8.49/moRequired, from $6/mo on a 2-year termRequired, rate not published

A note on how to read that table: these are the manufacturers' own published figures, cited below with the date each was read. Where a brand does not publish something we leave the cell empty rather than filling it from a competitor's review, which is why two of Tractive's and Fi's cells say so plainly.

Where SATELLAI genuinely wins

It is a fence and a tracker in one purchase. This is the real argument for it. If what you actually want is for the dog to stay in the yard, the alternative is a dedicated GPS fence plus a separate tracker, which is two devices on one dog's neck and two things to charge. The no-fee fence options are here if avoiding a subscription matters more than having one collar.

The battery claim is the strongest of the three that publish a number. SATELLAI states up to three days in active use from a 1600 mAh cell and describes that as roughly twice the capacity of most collars. Treat any stated day-count as a ceiling measured under favorable conditions — update frequency and cold weather both cut it — but three days of headroom is a real difference from a collar you charge every other evening.

Two-way audio is unusual at this price point. Whether it earns its place depends entirely on your dog; it is the kind of feature that sounds decisive in a spec list and goes unused in practice. We mention it because SATELLAI publishes it, not because we can tell you it works well.

Where SATELLAI does not win

The plan costs more. $305.64 versus Tractive's $252 at each brand's cheapest advertised rate. If you want tracking only, you are paying $54 extra over three years for a fence you will not use.

Dense woods are explicitly out of scope. SATELLAI's own will-it-work-here guide lists dense woods as not suitable and names good LTE coverage and residential open areas as the conditions it works best in. That is a straight answer from the manufacturer and we would rather repeat it than bury it: if you walk your dog under heavy canopy, this is the wrong collar and a radio system is the right one. What to use where there is no signal.

It is a newer platform than Tractive. Tractive has been the default answer in this category for years and is the one most likely to still be running in three years; it has also absorbed a competitor, which is the direction of travel in pet GPS. That is a reason to weight platform longevity when you are committing to thirty-six months of payments on any of these.

A neck-size check before you buy

SATELLAI states a 14–30 inch neck range. That covers most medium and large dogs and rules out small breeds at the bottom end — a dog with a neck under fourteen inches does not fit, and no amount of strap adjustment changes that. Tractive, because it clips to whatever collar the dog already wears, has no such constraint, which is one practical reason it stays our default recommendation for small dogs.

Top pickPlan required

Best cellular dog collar, compared

Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

The most mature platform in pet GPS and the cheapest plan here: $252 across three years on Basic.

$47.40Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker on Amazon

$79.0040% off

Price as of November 20, 2026. Prices move — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

Read the full write-up on the Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

The short answer

Quick picks

Ranked by what each one costs to own for three years, not by sticker price. The plan column is the one most comparisons leave out.

#ProductBest forPlan / 3 yrPrice
01
Tractive Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker
Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

The most mature platform in pet GPS and the cheapest plan here: $252 across three years on Basic. It clips to the collar you already own, which is the other reason most owners should start here.

Best overall, and the cheapest plan of the threePlan required

+$252 / 3 yr

$47.40Amazon
02
SATELLAI SATELLAI Collar
SATELLAI Collar

The only one of the three that is a virtual fence as well as a tracker. SATELLAI states unlimited fences, two-way audio, IP68 and up to three days of active battery — but the telecom plan is mandatory and works out at $305.64 over three years, which is more than Tractive's.

Best if you want the fence built inPlan required

+$306 / 3 yr

Check price →

Code SATELLAIPTN: $55 off at satellai.com

03
Fi Fi Series 3+ GPS dog collar
Fi Series 3+ GPS dog collar

The tracker is the collar rather than a module clipped to one, and the battery claim is the longest in cellular pet tracking. The membership is required and Fi does not publish a rate we can cite, so it is the one of the three you cannot cost in advance.

Best-integrated collar, if you accept an unpublished ratePlan required

Plan required

$64.50Amazon

#ad · Live prices from Amazon's product API, as of November 20, 2026. Where we have no verified live price we show none — a gap beats a number that has rotted. Plan figures are the brands' own published rates, cited in Sources below.

In detail

The picks, in full

Tractive Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker
$47.40Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker on Amazon

$79.0040% off

Price as of November 20, 2026. Prices move — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

Top pickPlan required#01 · Tractive

Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

Best overall, and the cheapest plan of the three

The most mature platform in pet GPS and the cheapest plan here: $252 across three years on Basic. It clips to the collar you already own, which is the other reason most owners should start here.

The subscription reality

The collar is useless without a plan — the subscription pays for the SIM inside it. The cheapest honest route to three years on Basic is $252.

Published monthly:
$9 Basic (1-year), $6 Basic (2-year)
Over three years:
$252 on Basic (a 2-year term at $144 plus a 1-year at $108)

Specs, as published by Tractive

  • Clips to any collar, cellular with built-in SIM
  • Virtual fence alerts
  • Live tracking with a walk-to-it mode

Good

  • The best-supported pet GPS on the market, and the one most likely to still exist in three years
  • Genuinely live tracking, which is what you need for a dog that runs
  • Virtual fence alerts actually work

Not so good

  • Needs a plan. $252 over three years on Basic is the realistic figure, and that is before the collar
  • Charge every few days
  • The plan is per tracker, so two dogs is two plans

Skip it if

your dog never leaves a fenced garden. For that dog a $25 Bluetooth tag and a sturdy latch is the better purchase.

SATELLAI SATELLAI Collar
See today's price on the SATELLAI Collar →

Sold direct by the brand. The current price and plan options are on their site.

Code SATELLAIPTN: $55 off at satellai.com

If that one does not apply to your cart, code JM4PYFPQARH2: $50 off the SATELLAI Collar.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to SATELLAI Collar

Plan required#02 · SATELLAI

SATELLAI Collar

Best if you want the fence built in

The only one of the three that is a virtual fence as well as a tracker. SATELLAI states unlimited fences, two-way audio, IP68 and up to three days of active battery — but the telecom plan is mandatory and works out at $305.64 over three years, which is more than Tractive's.

The subscription reality

A telecom plan is required to activate the collar and keep the GPS working — SATELLAI states so on the product page. The cheapest advertised rate is $8.49 a month, which is $305.64 across thirty-six months, so the plan costs appreciably more than most collars in this category do.

Published monthly:
from $8.49, per SATELLAI's own product page
Over three years:
$305.64 at the cheapest rate SATELLAI publishes

Specs, as published by SATELLAI

  • Dual-band GNSS across 5 constellations with dual antennas, per SATELLAI
  • Up to 3 days of battery in active use, or up to 10 days standby, on a 1600 mAh cell
  • IP68 waterproof, with two-way audio and unlimited virtual fences
  • LTE updates stated as every second across 680+ networks

Good

  • The longest stated active battery of the cellular dog collars here, from a cell SATELLAI puts at 1600 mAh
  • Unlimited virtual fences and two-way audio in one collar, which usually means buying a fence system separately
  • IP68 and a 14-30 inch neck range, so it suits a water-loving dog and most sizes

Not so good

  • A telecom plan is required — the collar does not work without one
  • $8.49 a month is $305.64 across three years, on top of the collar
  • SATELLAI's own fit guide says it is not suitable for dense woods, because the fence and tracking lean on LTE and GPS

Skip it if

you walk your dog mostly under heavy tree cover — SATELLAI itself lists dense woods as unsuitable, and a fence that needs a clean GPS fix is the wrong tool there.

Fi Fi Series 3+ GPS dog collar
$64.50Fi Series 3+ GPS dog collar on Amazon

$129.0050% off

Price as of November 20, 2026. Prices move — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Fi Series 3+ GPS dog collar

Plan required#03 · Fi

Fi Series 3+ GPS dog collar

Best-integrated collar, if you accept an unpublished rate

The tracker is the collar rather than a module clipped to one, and the battery claim is the longest in cellular pet tracking. The membership is required and Fi does not publish a rate we can cite, so it is the one of the three you cannot cost in advance.

The subscription reality

Fi states on its own Amazon listing that a membership is required. Fi's own site now lives at fitracking.com — tryfi.com 301-redirects there, which is worth knowing before you commit three years of payments to a brand.

Specs, as published by Fi

  • The tracker is the collar, not a clip-on
  • Long stated battery life for a cellular pet tracker
  • Escape detection tied to your home Wi-Fi

Good

  • Best-looking and best-integrated pet collar here — no dangling module
  • Battery life is the longest claim in cellular pet tracking
  • Escape detection via home Wi-Fi is clever and works the way owners actually think

Not so good

  • Membership required, stated on Fi's own listing
  • tryfi.com now 301-redirects to fitracking.com — a rebrand to check before a three-year commitment
  • Expensive collar on top of the membership

Skip it if

you want to keep your dog's existing collar. With Fi, the collar is the product.

Which to buy, in one paragraph each

Buy Tractive if you want to know where the dog is, you want the cheapest plan you can actually cite before you commit, and you would rather keep the collar the dog already wears. It is the default for a reason.

Buy the SATELLAI Collar if the problem you are solving is the dog leaving the yard rather than the dog being lost — you want a virtual fence, and having it in the same collar as the tracker is worth $54 more over three years than Tractive's plan. Check the neck size and check your LTE coverage first.

Buy Fi if you want the tidiest object of the three and you are relaxed about a membership rate you cannot look up in advance. Price it at checkout before you commit, because we cannot price it for you.

What none of these three solve

All three are cellular, which means all three need a tower. In genuine dead zones — deep woods, canyon country, large tracts of unserved rural land — none of them reports, and the answer is radio direction-finding rather than a better cellular collar. The radio systems hunters actually use cost more once and nothing monthly.

And if the honest answer is that your dog bolts out of the front door twice a year in a suburb full of phones, none of these is the proportionate purchase. A tag in a collar holder covers that case for a few dollars and no plan at all.

In short

Our recommendation

Top pickPlan required

Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

Best overall, and the cheapest plan of the three

The most mature platform in pet GPS and the cheapest plan here: $252 across three years on Basic.

$47.40Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker on Amazon

$79.0040% off

Price as of November 20, 2026. Prices move — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

Runner-upPlan required

SATELLAI Collar

Best if you want the fence built in

The only one of the three that is a virtual fence as well as a tracker.

See today's price on the SATELLAI Collar →

Sold direct by the brand. The current price and plan options are on their site.

Code SATELLAIPTN: $55 off at satellai.com

If that one does not apply to your cart, code JM4PYFPQARH2: $50 off the SATELLAI Collar.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to SATELLAI Collar

Still deciding on the running cost rather than the device? Every tracker subscription, costed over three years.

How we picked

Researched from published specs and real plan prices

Every pick here is researched from the manufacturer's published specifications, each one cited with the date it was read, and from the brand's own published subscription rate — then costed out over thirty-six months so you can see what the device really comes to. Device prices come live from Amazon's API and expire after 48 hours, so the number you see is current. Where a figure is not published by the manufacturer, the page says the spec is unconfirmed rather than borrowing it from a competitor's review. The full method is on the methodology page.

Working out what a tracker really costs? See the three-year cost of every tracker, compared.

Questions

Frequently asked

Does the SATELLAI Collar need a subscription?
Yes. SATELLAI states on its own product page that a telecom plan is required to activate the collar and maintain the GPS services and cellular data. The cheapest rate it advertises is $8.49 a month, which comes to $305.64 across thirty-six months — more than Tractive's $252 on Basic, and on top of the collar itself.
Is SATELLAI cheaper than Tractive?
Not on the plan, which is the part that compounds. At each brand's cheapest advertised rate SATELLAI is $305.64 over three years against Tractive's $252, so Tractive is about $54 cheaper to run. Device prices move, so check both at checkout — but the plan gap is the figure to decide on.
How long does the SATELLAI Collar battery last?
SATELLAI states up to 3 days of battery life during active use, or up to 10 days of standby when idle, from a 1600 mAh cell it describes as roughly twice the capacity of most collars, with a 2-hour charge. Treat stated day-counts as a warm-weather ceiling: update frequency and cold both reduce them.
Does the SATELLAI Collar work in the woods?
SATELLAI itself says no. Its will-it-work-here guide names good LTE coverage and residential open areas as the conditions it suits, and lists dense woods as not suitable. If your dog runs under heavy tree cover, a radio direction-finding system is the right technology and no cellular collar is.
Which of the three has a virtual fence?
All three do something fence-shaped, but they are not the same feature. SATELLAI states unlimited virtual fences with customizable feedback — it is sold as a GPS fence first. Tractive publishes virtual fence alerts. Fi's equivalent is escape detection tied to your home Wi-Fi rather than a drawn boundary. If the fence is the point, SATELLAI is the one built around it.
Will the SATELLAI Collar fit a small dog?
Only down to a point. SATELLAI states a 14 to 30 inch neck range, so a dog with a neck under fourteen inches will not fit it. A clip-on tracker like Tractive sidesteps the problem entirely because it attaches to whatever collar already fits.

Read next

Where the figures came from

Sources

Every specification and plan price on this page traces to one of these, read on the date shown. Device prices are live from Amazon and stamped separately.

  1. SATELLAI — SATELLAI Collar product page: "Telecom plans starting at $8.49/mo.", "A telecom plan is required to activate the collar and maintain the GPS services, cellular data", "Up to 3 days of battery life during active use, or up to 10 days of standby time when idle", "The double-sized 1600mAh battery", dual-band GNSS across "5 constellations, dual antennas", "Updates your dog's location every second with reliable LTE coverage across 680+ networks globally", "IP68-rated waterproof design", two-way audio, unlimited virtual fences, 14"-30" neck size, and a fit guide listing "Good LTE/4G coverage" and "Residential Open Area" as suitable and "Dense Woods" as not suitable — accessed 2026-11-07
  2. Tractive — subscription plans (Basic $9/mo 1-year, $6/mo 2-year; Premium $10/$7/$5) — accessed 2026-10-05
  3. tryfi.com — returns HTTP 301 to fitracking.com (checked directly) — accessed 2026-10-05
  4. Amazon Product Advertising / Creators API — live prices and product images — accessed 2026-10-05

Brands: want your product tested? For Brands.