Skip to content
Tag & Tether

Pets · Dog & Cat Trackers

Fi collar alternatives

Fi built the nicest cellular dog collar on the market. People go looking for an alternative because of the membership, the price, or because they want to keep their own collar - so this page is sorted by which of those it is.

By Mike M.Last updated

#ad — we earn a commission if you buy through the links on this page, at no cost to you, from Amazon and from brand partner programs. It never changes the order: our top pick is routinely the cheapest option to own over three years rather than the best-paying one. Full disclosure.


If you want what Fi does without the Fi deal, buy a Tractive: same live LTE tracking from the biggest platform in the category, clipped to the collar your dog already wears, with a published plan price of $252 across three years. If you want a collar-integrated unit with a virtual fence built in, look at SATELLAI. And if the real objection is subscriptions, the only honest answer is a change of technology - a no-fee radio system, or a $30 tag for the dog that never actually leaves the yard.

First, what Fi is known for, because this page is not an argument that Fi is bad. It is the best-integrated cellular dog collar anybody makes: the tracker is the collar rather than a module hanging off one, which is why Fi collars look like equipment instead of a science project. It carries the longest battery claim in cellular pet tracking. And its escape detection is tied to your home Wi-Fi, so the system understands “home” the way an owner does and tells you when the dog has left it. If you have seen one on another dog at the park and thought it looked better than yours, you were right.

People go looking for an alternative for three specific reasons, and none of them is that the product does not work.

Reason one: the membership

A membership is required - Fi states that on its own listing - so the collar is a hardware purchase plus an ongoing commitment, and it is the ongoing part that sends most people to a search box. This site exists for that reader, so we will put the general principle plainly: in pet tracking the subscription is usually the business, and the hardware is the customer acquisition cost. That is not unique to Fi. Tractive, SATELLAI, Pawfit and Whistle all require a plan, because a cellular collar contains a SIM and somebody has to pay a carrier for the data.

What differs enormously is whether a company publishes the number. Tractive publishes rates you can check before you buy, and ours work out at $252 across thirty-six months on Basic. SATELLAI publishes a starting rate of $8.49 a month, which is $305.64 across the same period. Several brands in this category publish nothing on a static page at all. Our three-year cost table for every tracker we cover exists so you can compare the real figures in one place rather than one checkout at a time.

Reason two: the collar is the product

With Fi, you are not adding a tracker to your dog’s collar. You are replacing the collar. That is exactly why the result looks so good, and it is also a genuine constraint: you cannot keep the collar you already own and like, a growing puppy means sizing decisions, and a damaged strap is a hardware problem rather than a five-dollar trip to the pet store.

Clip-on trackers invert that trade. A Tractive or Pawfit module goes onto any strap, so the collar stays yours and the tracker is a part you can move between collars, or between dogs. It is less elegant on the dog. It is also less locked-in, which for some owners is the whole point.

Reason three: the brand moved

One factual note, offered as diligence rather than criticism: Fi’s own site now lives at fitracking.com, and tryfi.com returns a permanent redirect there. Rebrands and domain moves are routine and plenty of healthy companies do them. But in this category the device stops working if the service stops - that is the nature of a cellular tracker - so before committing to three years of payments with anybody, it is reasonable to notice who you are committing to. The same diligence applies across the market: our main dog tracker roundup notes where brands have been absorbed, because it has happened more than once here.

Which alternative matches which objection

The picks above are ordered to answer that question directly rather than by price.

You want the same capability with a published plan price and no lock-in to one strap: Tractive. It is the most-supported platform in the category and the likeliest to still be running in three years, which in a subscription product is not a small consideration.

You liked the all-in-one collar and want containment as well: SATELLAI, with the clear caveat that its plan costs more across three years than Tractive’s, not less, and that SATELLAI itself rules out dense woods.

The up-front hardware price was the blocker: Pawfit 3, accepting a smaller platform and an unpublished plan rate.

You are done with subscriptions on principle: a radio system. eMACROS is the budget end of that technology; there are bigger handheld systems if you want range and multiple collars, covered in our roundup of dog trackers with no subscription. Radio means no app and no remote checking - you have to be out there with the handheld - and in exchange nothing is billed and nothing can be switched off.

Honestly, your dog does not roam: a tag and a collar holder, for about thirty dollars, once. The difference between a tracker and a finder is the thing to read before you decide which of those two you actually need, because it is the one decision on this page that cannot be fixed with money later.

Top pickPlan required

Best Fi alternative

Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

The alternative most people should look at first.

$47.40Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker on Amazon

$79.0040% off

Price as of November 20, 2026. Prices move — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

Read the full write-up on the Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

The short answer

Quick picks

Ranked by what each one costs to own for three years, not by sticker price. The plan column is the one most comparisons leave out.

#ProductBest forPlan / 3 yrPrice
01
Tractive Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker
Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

The alternative most people should look at first. It does the same job as Fi from the largest and best-supported platform in pet tracking: live LTE position, virtual fence alerts and a walk-to-it mode, on a module that clips to whatever collar your dog already wears. That last part is the real difference - you are adding a tracker to your dog rather than replacing the collar - and it also means a chewed strap costs five dollars instead of a hardware order. The plan is still mandatory and it is still the bulk of the cost: $252 across three years on Basic by Tractive's own published rates, charged per tracker, so two dogs is two plans.

Best overall alternative - same job, bigger platformPlan required

+$252 / 3 yr

$47.40Amazon
02
SATELLAI SATELLAI Collar
SATELLAI Collar

The closest thing here to Fi's design philosophy - the electronics live in the collar rather than dangling from it - and it adds something Fi does not: unlimited virtual fences and two-way audio in the same unit, which otherwise means buying a containment system separately. SATELLAI states dual-band GNSS across five constellations, IP68, and up to three days of active battery from a 1600 mAh cell. Be clear-eyed about the cost: the telecom plan is mandatory and starts at $8.49 a month by SATELLAI's own figure, which is $305.64 across three years - more than Tractive, not less - and SATELLAI's own fit guide lists dense woods as unsuitable.

If you liked the all-in-one collar, and want a fence tooPlan required

+$306 / 3 yr

Check price →

Code SATELLAIPTN: $55 off at satellai.com

03
Pawfit Pawfit 3 pet GPS tracker
Pawfit 3 pet GPS tracker

The option for somebody whose problem is the up-front cost rather than the subscription model. Pawfit undercuts the collar-integrated products on hardware while doing the core job - 4G live tracking plus activity monitoring on a collar-mounted module. Two caveats we would want to know. A plan is still required, and Pawfit does not publish a rate on a static page we can cite, so the subscription is a number you discover at checkout rather than before it. And it is a much smaller platform than Tractive or Fi, which matters in a category where the service is the product and companies do get absorbed.

If the hardware price is what stopped youPlan required

Plan required

$59.99Amazon
04
eMACROS eMACROS dog GPS tracker, no subscription
eMACROS dog GPS tracker, no subscription

The genuine answer to the version of this search that ends in 'no subscription', and it gets there by changing the technology rather than the brand. A radio link runs directly between a handheld and the collar unit, so there is no SIM, no carrier, no account and nothing that can lapse, and the manufacturer states up to three miles of range. It also keeps working in the dead zones where every cellular collar - Fi's included - goes silent. What you give up is substantial and worth saying plainly: no phone app, no map you can check from work, and a line-of-sight range that hills and trees cut hard.

If you want no subscription at all, everNo monthly fee

$0

$111.99Amazon
05
Apple Apple AirTag (2nd generation)
Apple AirTag (2nd generation)

Worth considering honestly before spending three figures plus a membership: a large share of dogs never leave a fenced yard, and for that dog a crowd-network tag is the better purchase. An AirTag has no GPS - it reports when somebody else's iPhone passes within Bluetooth range - but Apple's is the densest finding network in the world, so a dog that slips a gate in a neighborhood usually shows a position quickly. No subscription, ever, and a coin cell about once a year. It is the wrong product for a dog that genuinely covers ground, and it needs an iPhone household.

If the dog does not actually runNo monthly fee

$0 + batteries

$23.00Amazon
06
GOCII Waterproof AirTag dog collar holder (2-pack)
Waterproof AirTag dog collar holder (2-pack)

The cheapest line item on this page and the piece people forget to budget for. A waterproof silicone case threads the tag flat onto the collar strap instead of letting it swing off a D-ring, which is what stops a dog chewing it loose and stops it rattling all day. Two per pack, so a second dog is covered. It changes nothing about what the tag can do - no holder turns a Bluetooth tag into a GPS collar - but it is the difference between a tag that stays on the dog and one you find in the yard.

Budget pick - the part that makes a tag a collar trackerNo monthly fee

$0

$5.30Amazon
07
Halo Halo Collar 5
Halo Collar 5

Some people shopping for a Fi alternative do not want tracking at all; they want the dog to stay in the yard. This is that product: a GPS wireless fence with app-drawn boundaries, activity tracking and a structured training program, and the app and content are genuinely polished. It is the opposite of an escape from a subscription, though - features are explicitly tiered behind one, so read the tier list before you buy and check which boundary features sit on which tier. It also shares the limitation of every wireless fence: boundaries depend on a clean GPS fix, which heavy tree canopy degrades.

If containment was the feature you actually wantedPlan required

Plan required

$419.00Amazon

#ad · Live prices from Amazon's product API, as of November 20, 2026. Where we have no verified live price we show none — a gap beats a number that has rotted. Plan figures are the brands' own published rates, cited in Sources below.

In detail

The picks, in full

Tractive Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker
$47.40Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker on Amazon

$79.0040% off

Price as of November 20, 2026. Prices move — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

Top pickPlan required#01 · Tractive

Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

Best overall alternative - same job, bigger platform

The alternative most people should look at first. It does the same job as Fi from the largest and best-supported platform in pet tracking: live LTE position, virtual fence alerts and a walk-to-it mode, on a module that clips to whatever collar your dog already wears. That last part is the real difference - you are adding a tracker to your dog rather than replacing the collar - and it also means a chewed strap costs five dollars instead of a hardware order. The plan is still mandatory and it is still the bulk of the cost: $252 across three years on Basic by Tractive's own published rates, charged per tracker, so two dogs is two plans.

The subscription reality

The collar is useless without a plan — the subscription pays for the SIM inside it. The cheapest honest route to three years on Basic is $252.

Published monthly:
$9 Basic (1-year), $6 Basic (2-year)
Over three years:
$252 on Basic (a 2-year term at $144 plus a 1-year at $108)

Specs, as published by Tractive

  • Clips to any collar, cellular with built-in SIM
  • Virtual fence alerts
  • Live tracking with a walk-to-it mode

Good

  • The best-supported pet GPS on the market, and the one most likely to still exist in three years
  • Genuinely live tracking, which is what you need for a dog that runs
  • Virtual fence alerts actually work

Not so good

  • Needs a plan. $252 over three years on Basic is the realistic figure, and that is before the collar
  • Charge every few days
  • The plan is per tracker, so two dogs is two plans

Skip it if

your dog never leaves a fenced garden. For that dog a $25 Bluetooth tag and a sturdy latch is the better purchase.

SATELLAI SATELLAI Collar
See today's price on the SATELLAI Collar →

Sold direct by the brand. The current price and plan options are on their site.

Code SATELLAIPTN: $55 off at satellai.com

If that one does not apply to your cart, code JM4PYFPQARH2: $50 off the SATELLAI Collar.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to SATELLAI Collar

Plan required#02 · SATELLAI

SATELLAI Collar

If you liked the all-in-one collar, and want a fence too

The closest thing here to Fi's design philosophy - the electronics live in the collar rather than dangling from it - and it adds something Fi does not: unlimited virtual fences and two-way audio in the same unit, which otherwise means buying a containment system separately. SATELLAI states dual-band GNSS across five constellations, IP68, and up to three days of active battery from a 1600 mAh cell. Be clear-eyed about the cost: the telecom plan is mandatory and starts at $8.49 a month by SATELLAI's own figure, which is $305.64 across three years - more than Tractive, not less - and SATELLAI's own fit guide lists dense woods as unsuitable.

The subscription reality

A telecom plan is required to activate the collar and keep the GPS working — SATELLAI states so on the product page. The cheapest advertised rate is $8.49 a month, which is $305.64 across thirty-six months, so the plan costs appreciably more than most collars in this category do.

Published monthly:
from $8.49, per SATELLAI's own product page
Over three years:
$305.64 at the cheapest rate SATELLAI publishes

Specs, as published by SATELLAI

  • Dual-band GNSS across 5 constellations with dual antennas, per SATELLAI
  • Up to 3 days of battery in active use, or up to 10 days standby, on a 1600 mAh cell
  • IP68 waterproof, with two-way audio and unlimited virtual fences
  • LTE updates stated as every second across 680+ networks

Good

  • The longest stated active battery of the cellular dog collars here, from a cell SATELLAI puts at 1600 mAh
  • Unlimited virtual fences and two-way audio in one collar, which usually means buying a fence system separately
  • IP68 and a 14-30 inch neck range, so it suits a water-loving dog and most sizes

Not so good

  • A telecom plan is required — the collar does not work without one
  • $8.49 a month is $305.64 across three years, on top of the collar
  • SATELLAI's own fit guide says it is not suitable for dense woods, because the fence and tracking lean on LTE and GPS

Skip it if

you walk your dog mostly under heavy tree cover — SATELLAI itself lists dense woods as unsuitable, and a fence that needs a clean GPS fix is the wrong tool there.

Pawfit Pawfit 3 pet GPS tracker
$59.99Pawfit 3 pet GPS tracker on Amazon

Price as of November 20, 2026. Prices move — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Pawfit 3 pet GPS tracker

Plan required#03 · Pawfit

Pawfit 3 pet GPS tracker

If the hardware price is what stopped you

The option for somebody whose problem is the up-front cost rather than the subscription model. Pawfit undercuts the collar-integrated products on hardware while doing the core job - 4G live tracking plus activity monitoring on a collar-mounted module. Two caveats we would want to know. A plan is still required, and Pawfit does not publish a rate on a static page we can cite, so the subscription is a number you discover at checkout rather than before it. And it is a much smaller platform than Tractive or Fi, which matters in a category where the service is the product and companies do get absorbed.

The subscription reality

A cellular tracker needs a data plan to report its position. This brand does not publish a plan rate we can cite, so treat the device price as a deposit rather than the cost.

Specs, as published by Pawfit

  • 4G cellular, collar-mounted
  • Live tracking plus activity monitoring
  • Two-way sound features on some models

Good

  • Cheaper hardware than Tractive
  • 4G live tracking
  • Good battery for the price

Not so good

  • Plan required
  • Smaller platform than Tractive, so longevity is less certain
  • Plan rate not published on a static page we can cite

Skip it if

platform longevity matters more than $20 of hardware saving.

eMACROS eMACROS dog GPS tracker, no subscription
$111.99eMACROS dog GPS tracker on Amazon

$139.9920% off

Price as of November 20, 2026. Prices move — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to eMACROS dog GPS tracker, no subscription

No monthly fee#04 · eMACROS

eMACROS dog GPS tracker, no subscription

If you want no subscription at all, ever

The genuine answer to the version of this search that ends in 'no subscription', and it gets there by changing the technology rather than the brand. A radio link runs directly between a handheld and the collar unit, so there is no SIM, no carrier, no account and nothing that can lapse, and the manufacturer states up to three miles of range. It also keeps working in the dead zones where every cellular collar - Fi's included - goes silent. What you give up is substantial and worth saying plainly: no phone app, no map you can check from work, and a line-of-sight range that hills and trees cut hard.

The subscription reality

Radio direction-finding, not cellular. No SIM, no network, no plan — which is exactly why it still works where there is no signal.

Over three years:
$0

Specs, as published by eMACROS

  • Radio link between a handheld and the collar unit — no SIM, no cellular
  • Manufacturer states up to 3 miles of range
  • Works off-grid where there is no phone signal

Good

  • No subscription, ever, because there is no network involved
  • Works in dead zones, which is precisely where cellular pet trackers fail
  • No app, no account, no servers that can be switched off

Not so good

  • You carry a handheld — there is no phone app and no map you can check from work
  • Range is line-of-sight; hills and trees cut it hard
  • Stated 3 miles is a best case, as every radio range figure is

Skip it if

you want to check on the dog from your desk. Radio direction-finding only works when you are out there holding the handheld.

Apple Apple AirTag (2nd generation)
$23.00Apple AirTag on Amazon

$29.0021% off

Price as of November 20, 2026. Prices move — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Apple AirTag (2nd generation)

No monthly fee#05 · Apple

Apple AirTag (2nd generation)

If the dog does not actually run

Worth considering honestly before spending three figures plus a membership: a large share of dogs never leave a fenced yard, and for that dog a crowd-network tag is the better purchase. An AirTag has no GPS - it reports when somebody else's iPhone passes within Bluetooth range - but Apple's is the densest finding network in the world, so a dog that slips a gate in a neighborhood usually shows a position quickly. No subscription, ever, and a coin cell about once a year. It is the wrong product for a dog that genuinely covers ground, and it needs an iPhone household.

The subscription reality

No subscription. The only recurring cost is a CR2032 roughly once a year, which is pennies.

Over three years:
about $3 in coin cells

Specs, as published by Apple

  • User-replaceable CR2032 coin cell; Apple states it runs more than a year
  • IP67 (1 m for up to 30 minutes, IEC 60529)
  • Ultra Wideband Precision Finding, 1.5x the range of the first generation
  • Speaker 50% louder than the first generation

Good

  • No subscription, and Apple has never charged one
  • The Find My network is the largest crowd network in the world, so a lost AirTag in a populated area usually reports within minutes
  • Precision Finding walks you to it by distance and direction, not just a map pin
  • Battery is a coin cell from any supermarket, not a sealed pack

Not so good

  • iPhone only for setup and full use — there is no Android app
  • It has no GPS of its own: it reports when an Apple device walks past it, so it is a finder, not a tracker
  • No keyring hole, so you are buying a holder as well

Skip it if

you are on Android, or you need to watch something move in real time — an AirTag only knows where it was when someone last walked past it.

GOCII Waterproof AirTag dog collar holder (2-pack)
$5.30Waterproof AirTag dog collar holder on Amazon

$6.9824% off

Price as of November 20, 2026. Prices move — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Waterproof AirTag dog collar holder (2-pack)

No monthly fee#06 · GOCII

Waterproof AirTag dog collar holder (2-pack)

Budget pick - the part that makes a tag a collar tracker

The cheapest line item on this page and the piece people forget to budget for. A waterproof silicone case threads the tag flat onto the collar strap instead of letting it swing off a D-ring, which is what stops a dog chewing it loose and stops it rattling all day. Two per pack, so a second dog is covered. It changes nothing about what the tag can do - no holder turns a Bluetooth tag into a GPS collar - but it is the difference between a tag that stays on the dog and one you find in the yard.

The subscription reality

No subscription, now or later. The purchase price is the whole cost of ownership.

Over three years:
$0

Specs, as published by GOCII

  • Waterproof silicone case
  • Threads onto a collar strap
  • Two per pack

Good

  • Cheap
  • Survives a wet dog
  • Keeps the tag flat against the collar

Not so good

  • An AirTag on a collar is still only a finder, not a tracker
  • Can be chewed off
  • Adds a little weight

Skip it if

your dog roams out of sight. No holder turns a Bluetooth tag into a GPS collar — you need cellular or radio for that.

Halo Halo Collar 5
$419.00Halo Collar 5 on Amazon

$599.0030% off

Price as of November 20, 2026. Prices move — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Halo Collar 5

Plan required#07 · Halo

Halo Collar 5

If containment was the feature you actually wanted

Some people shopping for a Fi alternative do not want tracking at all; they want the dog to stay in the yard. This is that product: a GPS wireless fence with app-drawn boundaries, activity tracking and a structured training program, and the app and content are genuinely polished. It is the opposite of an escape from a subscription, though - features are explicitly tiered behind one, so read the tier list before you buy and check which boundary features sit on which tier. It also shares the limitation of every wireless fence: boundaries depend on a clean GPS fix, which heavy tree canopy degrades.

The subscription reality

A cellular tracker needs a data plan to report its position. This brand does not publish a plan rate we can cite, so treat the device price as a deposit rather than the cost.

Specs, as published by Halo

  • GPS wireless fence with app-drawn boundaries
  • Activity tracking and training program
  • Subscription tiers gate features

Good

  • Polished app and training content
  • Wire-free containment
  • Activity tracking

Not so good

  • Features are tiered behind a subscription
  • Expensive
  • Same GPS-under-canopy limitation as every wireless fence

Skip it if

you object to paying monthly for features already built into hardware you bought. That is exactly the model here.

What you give up by leaving Fi

A fair alternatives page has to say what the original still does better, so: the integrated collar is genuinely nicer than a module on a strap, the battery claim is the longest in cellular pet tracking, and Wi-Fi-anchored escape detection is a smarter way of defining “home” than a hand-drawn map circle. If those three things are what you want, no page can talk you into being happy with a clip-on module and you will end up back where you started.

What you gain by moving depends entirely on which objection you started with - a published plan rate, cheaper hardware, your own collar back, or no recurring bill at all. None of the alternatives above wins on all four.

How to compare these properly

Add thirty-six months before you compare anything. Device price plus three years of plan is the only number that means anything in this category, and it reorders the shortlist dramatically. A cheaper collar with a pricier plan is not cheaper.

Check whether the plan rate is published. A brand that puts its subscription price on a page you can read before buying is telling you something about how it intends to treat you later. Two of the picks above do; two do not.

Count the dogs. Cellular plans are per tracker, so the arithmetic doubles with the second dog and radio systems start to win outright - one handheld follows several collars with nothing recurring. Our multiple-dog page works through that properly.

Test your coverage where the dog actually goes. Every cellular collar, Fi’s included, needs a mobile signal at the animal to report anything. If your walking ground is a valley or a forestry block, the whole cellular category is the wrong answer and the rural and no-signal page is the one to read instead.

Pages that answer a nearby question

If what you actually want is the head-to-head rather than a shortlist, Tractive vs Fi compares the two collar systems directly, and SATELLAI vs Tractive vs Fi puts three of them side by side on plan cost and features. If you came here from the other direction - happy with a clip-on module but unhappy with Tractive’s billing - Tractive alternatives is the mirror image of this page.

In short

Our recommendation

Top pickPlan required

Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

Best overall alternative - same job, bigger platform

The alternative most people should look at first.

$47.40Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker on Amazon

$79.0040% off

Price as of November 20, 2026. Prices move — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Tractive Smart Dog GPS tracker

Runner-upPlan required

SATELLAI Collar

If you liked the all-in-one collar, and want a fence too

The closest thing here to Fi's design philosophy - the electronics live in the collar rather than dangling from it - and it adds something Fi does not: unlimited virtual fences and two-way audio in the same unit, which otherwise means buying a containment system separately.

See today's price on the SATELLAI Collar →

Sold direct by the brand. The current price and plan options are on their site.

Code SATELLAIPTN: $55 off at satellai.com

If that one does not apply to your cart, code JM4PYFPQARH2: $50 off the SATELLAI Collar.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to SATELLAI Collar

Still deciding on the running cost rather than the device? Every tracker subscription, costed over three years.

How we picked

Researched from published specs and real plan prices

Every pick here is researched from the manufacturer's published specifications, each one cited with the date it was read, and from the brand's own published subscription rate — then costed out over thirty-six months so you can see what the device really comes to. Device prices come live from Amazon's API and expire after 48 hours, so the number you see is current. Where a figure is not published by the manufacturer, the page says the spec is unconfirmed rather than borrowing it from a competitor's review. The full method is on the methodology page.

Working out what a tracker really costs? See the three-year cost of every tracker, compared.

Questions

Frequently asked

Does the Fi collar require a subscription?
Yes. Fi states on its own Amazon listing that a membership is required, which is normal for the category rather than unusual: a cellular collar contains a SIM, and the data has to be paid for. What that means practically is that the collar price is not the cost of ownership - you are signing up for hardware plus an ongoing payment, and the ongoing payment is what most people are reacting to when they search for an alternative.
What is the closest alternative to a Fi collar?
Tractive, for most people. It does the same core job - live LTE position, virtual fence alerts, walk-to-it mode - from the largest and best-supported platform in pet tracking, and it publishes its plan prices, which work out at $252 over three years on the Basic tier. The difference in shape is that Tractive clips to the collar your dog already wears instead of being the collar. If the integrated collar form factor is what you liked about Fi, SATELLAI is closer on that specific point.
Is there a Fi alternative with no monthly fee?
Not in the same form. A collar that reports a live position from anywhere needs a cellular connection, and that is a recurring cost no matter whose name is on it. There are two genuine no-fee routes and both change the technology. Radio direction-finding systems have no SIM and no plan at all, and they work off-grid, but you carry a handheld and there is no phone app. Bluetooth crowd-network tags like an AirTag cost nothing per month and work well in populated areas, but they only report when a stranger's phone passes the dog.
Can I use a Fi collar without the membership?
Not for tracking. Across this category, when a plan lapses the device stops reporting positions, because the cellular connection is the part the plan pays for. Treat any cellular collar as a subscription with hardware attached rather than hardware with an optional service, and price thirty-six months before you buy. That is the single most useful habit in this whole category.
Did Fi go out of business?
No. What happened is a domain move: Fi's site now lives at fitracking.com and tryfi.com returns a permanent redirect there, which we checked directly. Rebrands are routine. We mention it only because a cellular tracker depends on the company's service staying switched on, so knowing who you are buying a three-year relationship from is reasonable diligence with any brand here, including the alternatives on this page.
Is Tractive cheaper than Fi overall?
On the plan, Tractive publishes rates that come to $252 across three years on Basic, and Fi does not publish a membership rate on a static page we can cite, so we will not print a comparison figure we cannot source. What we can say is how to do the comparison yourself in two minutes: get the membership price at Fi's checkout, multiply by thirty-six, add the collar, and set that beside $252 plus a Tractive. Whichever way that lands for you, it is the only comparison that matters.
What if I want a fence rather than a tracker?
Then buy a fence deliberately instead of hoping a tracker does the job. A tracker tells you where the dog is; a GPS fence tries to keep the dog somewhere, with a boundary you draw and a warning tone as the dog approaches it. SATELLAI includes both in one collar, Halo is a dedicated fence with tiered subscription features, and our page on GPS dog fences without a monthly fee covers how well the technology holds up and where tree cover defeats it.

Read next

Where the figures came from

Sources

Every specification and plan price on this page traces to one of these, read on the date shown. Device prices are live from Amazon and stamped separately.

  1. tryfi.com — returns HTTP 301 to fitracking.com (checked directly) — accessed 2026-10-05
  2. Tractive — subscription plans (Basic $9/mo 1-year, $6/mo 2-year; Premium $10/$7/$5) — accessed 2026-10-05
  3. SATELLAI — SATELLAI Collar product page: "Telecom plans starting at $8.49/mo.", "A telecom plan is required to activate the collar and maintain the GPS services, cellular data", "Up to 3 days of battery life during active use, or up to 10 days of standby time when idle", "The double-sized 1600mAh battery", dual-band GNSS across "5 constellations, dual antennas", "Updates your dog's location every second with reliable LTE coverage across 680+ networks globally", "IP68-rated waterproof design", two-way audio, unlimited virtual fences, 14"-30" neck size, and a fit guide listing "Good LTE/4G coverage" and "Residential Open Area" as suitable and "Dense Woods" as not suitable — accessed 2026-11-07
  4. Apple — AirTag product page (battery, IP67, Precision Finding) — accessed 2026-10-05
  5. Amazon Product Advertising / Creators API — live prices and product images — accessed 2026-10-05

Brands: want your product tested? For Brands.